Back in 1950, Alan Turing wrote a paper called “Computing Machinery and Intelligence,” which attempted to tackle the tricky topic of whether machines are technically capable of showing intelligent behavior. In the paper, Turing proposed a test based on the Imitation Game — a party game where a man and a woman go into separate rooms, and then the other partygoers have to try and tell them apart by sending them questions and reading their typewritten responses. In the original Turing Test, one of the rooms contains a computer — and if it can fool the partygoers into thinking it’s a human, then it passes the test.
Diagram illustrating the Turing Test
By this point, you can probably tell that the Turing Test — especially the modern-day variation — is rather flawed. For a start, the judges already know ahead of time that computers are involved, and thus may be prejudiced to give a more optimistic (or cynical) response. We also don’t know what questions the judges asked (were they the right questions?) Presumably the test carried out at the Royal Society was double-blind (the judges didn’t know if they were talking to a human or a chatterbot), but the official press release doesn’t mention it, so maybe not (in which case, the results are worthless). But most of all, it’s important to note that the Turing Test doesn’t actually deal with actual intelligence — it’s only concerned with external behavior — how the machine acts — rather than what’s going on inside.
In the case of Eugene Goostman, all he has to do is imitate a 13-year-old boy from Odessa, Ukraine. He doesn’t actually have to think about anything, or show any signs of sentience. In actuality, many of these chatterbots are just simple machines that follow a completely predetermined set of rules; they don’t learn, and they’re totally incapable of reacting to new situations that they haven’t been programmed for. They’re not really intelligent; they’re just mediocre conversationalists. [Read: How to create a mind, or die ]
So, while it’s nice to finally have the Turing Test sewn up after 64 years, you don’t have to worry about Eugene going all super Skynet sentient on us. There are plenty of R&D groups that are working on real human-level intelligence that could eventually lead to Judgment Day-like scenarios — but all Eugene does is provide a 13-year-old Ukranian boy for lonely people to talk to. (He’s online incidentally, if you want to see if he can fool you into thinking he’s actually a human boy, but the website is down right now, probably due to excessive load.)
No comments:
Post a Comment